What it really costs to sell online: per-sale fees or a flat monthly fee

How to work out what an online store really costs you: plan, per-sale fees, payment processing and apps. With a worked example and a free calculator.

The kaptativa team6 min read
In short

What an online store costs is the sum of the plan, the platform’s fee on every sale, the payment processor’s fee and the apps you add. With small sales the per-sale fee barely matters; as you sell more, a flat monthly fee with no per-sale commission usually comes out cheaper.

The four costs you need to add up

When you compare platforms for selling online, it’s easy to look only at the plan price. But what you pay each month has four parts:

  • The platform plan. The monthly subscription.
  • The platform’s fee on each sale. A percentage of every order that the platform keeps on top of the plan. Not every platform charges it, and some drop it on higher tiers or only if you use their own payments.
  • The payment processing fee. What the card processor charges per transaction, typically a percentage plus a few cents. You pay this on any platform.
  • Apps and add-ons. Features that aren’t included and cost extra: wholesale price lists, invoicing, reports, abandoned-cart recovery.

Payment processing is always there. The one worth a close look is the second, because it grows with your sales without giving you anything more in return.

A worked example

Say a store sells $6,000 a month. The example is illustrative: percentages vary by platform and plan.

Platform with per-sale feeFlat fee, no per-sale fee
Monthly plan$30$45
Per-sale fee (1.5%)$90$0
Total per month$120$45
Total per year$1,440$540

With these numbers, the difference over a year is $900. And it widens as you grow: double the sales and the fee doubles, while the flat plan stays the same.

Run your own numbers with the commission calculator. It’s free and doesn’t ask you to sign up.

When each model makes sense

A cheap plan with a per-sale fee can make sense while you’re testing and selling little: you pay less up front, and the fee on small sales is small. The break-even point comes when the monthly fee exceeds the difference in plan price. From there on, every extra sale costs you more on the platform that takes a cut.

To find your break-even point:

  1. Subtract the price of the plan with fees from the price of the flat plan.
  2. Divide that number by the fee percentage.
  3. The result is the monthly sales above which the flat plan is cheaper.

In the example: (45 − 30) ÷ 0.015 = $1,000 a month. If you sell more than that, the flat fee wins.

What the price tag doesn’t show

Beyond the math, look at what each option includes. Some useful questions:

  • Are setup, design and catalog upload billed separately?
  • Are the features you need in the plan, or are they paid apps?
  • Can you download all your data if you ever leave?
  • How do you reach support, and how fast do they reply?

kaptativa plans have a flat monthly fee in US dollars, no per-sale commission, and setup included. See the point-by-point breakdown in the comparison.

Frequently asked questions

What is a per-sale fee on an online store?

It’s a percentage of every sale that the platform keeps on top of the monthly plan. It’s separate from the payment processing fee, which you pay on any platform.

When does a flat fee with no per-sale commission pay off?

When the monthly fee you’d pay exceeds the difference in plan price between the two options. You find it by dividing that difference by the fee percentage.

Put it into practice with your own system

We’ll show you what kaptativa would look like set up for your business, with your products or services.

Free, no commitment